The Winning LieLast week the GOP gave us a number of speakers drawing attention to the fact that Sen. McCain supported the Iraq war strategy known as "the surge", and that Sen. Obama did not. At times their criticism of Obama based on spurning the surge sank to the level of mockery.
Typically the speaker would say something about Obama declaring the war as lost and refusing to support the surge, at which point the crowd would boo loudly. They would follow this up and receive even louder cheers by saying that McCain supported the surge and now we are winning. There we find the lie.
The claim that we are winning in Iraq is a wonderful example of political misuse of our language. Winning, you understand, means being better off in some way, than you were before entering the competition.
About nine months ago, I had a serious car crash. The Ford Explorer I was driving (not too well, apparently) was totaled when I drove it into a tree. That impact got its start about one hundred meters away, where I drove over some ice covered by a thin layer of snow at the beginning of a left turn. At that point I lost control of where the car was going. My attempts at correction were either futile or over compensating. The car and I crossed the left lane of the two lane road and nearly hit a fence on that side of the road, but continuing in a nearly straight line we crossed the road and went head on into a tree on the right side. After the jolt, I was nearly overwhelmed by the sound of the horn blaring and the gunpowdery smell of the airbag propellant. I was alive and relatively uninjured ~ no hospital visit was required.
Our nation's experience in Iraq since 2003 has been like my adventure in the Explorer: poorly planned; an ineffective reaction to a precipitating event; involving unexpected results; loud; smoky; and, not fatal (except to the 4100 soldiers who have died in Iraq, and whom we are trained to ignore).
There is no way to win a car wreck. And there is no way to win a war. When you drop the first bomb, you are merely admitting that you have lost.
Oh, the one difference between the car crash and the war in Iraq: the tree survived my assault without any apparent harm.